Compounded semaglutide
Collective vs NewSelf
Quick answer
Collective costs $76 a real month and NewSelf costs $170 — a difference of $94 a month, or $1,133 a year. Both figures are computed from what each seller actually charges and how often, not from the price on its landing page.
Checked in . Both sellers are re-checked on the same schedule; a price either side changes after that date will not be reflected here until the next check.
Collective or NewSelf?
Collective is the cheaper way to start, at $76 a month against $170 for NewSelf, and since both charge one price whatever the dose, that gap of $94 holds all the way up. Collective's figure includes a monthly fee of $17 that NewSelf does not charge. NewSelf names 49 states; Collective does not say where it ships. NewSelf received an FDA warning letter in February 2026; Collective has none on record.
What each one bills
| Collective | NewSelf | |
|---|---|---|
| True monthly cost | $76 | $170 |
| Advertised as | $59 | $100 |
| Charged | every calendar month | every calendar month |
| Each charge | $59 | $170 |
| Price basis | the same at every dose | the same at every dose |
| Mandatory recurring fee | $17 a month | none found |
| States it names | not published | 49 states |
| FDA warning letter | none on record | yes |
We earn a commission if you start care through one of the links above, at no extra cost to you. Which of these two is cheaper is computed from what each one bills and nothing else.
Where they actually differ
- Only one carries a mandatory recurring fee. Collective: $17 a month. 360 of 382 sellers charge nothing like it.
- What they advertise is not what they bill. Collective advertises $59 and bills $76; NewSelf advertises $100 and bills $170.
How we know
Both figures were read on the seller’s own site and recomputed over a 30.4375-day calendar month from the charge and the billing period it covers. Neither is a seller’s own “/mo”. The full working for each — the charge, the period, the arithmetic and the date it was read — is on its own page: Collective and NewSelf. The method is set out in how we verify.
To compare any two sellers in the index rather than these two, use the comparison tool.